Investing

Rentvesting: Renting Where You Want, Buying Where You Can

Rent where you want to live, buy where the numbers work. It suits some people, and not for the reasons usually given.

Rentvesting means continuing to rent in an area you want to live in, while buying an investment property somewhere more affordable. It can get you into the market years earlier and the interest is generally deductible. The costs are real: you forfeit first home buyer duty concessions, you lose the capital gains exemption on your own home, and you carry a landlord’s obligations while still being a tenant.

Rentvesting became popular because the alternative for many people was not buying at all. It is a legitimate approach that suits particular circumstances well. It is also frequently presented as a clever hack, which understates what it costs.

The case for it

  • You buy sooner. A property in an affordable area needs a far smaller deposit than a home in an inner suburb, which can mean entering the market years earlier.
  • The interest is generally deductible, because the property produces income. Interest on your own home is not.
  • Tenants contribute. Rent covers a meaningful share of the holding cost, which your own mortgage does not.
  • You stay where your life is. Near work, family, schools or the lifestyle you actually want, rather than where you can afford to buy.
  • Flexibility. Ending a lease is far quicker and cheaper than selling a home, which matters if your work or circumstances may move.

The costs people understate

You give up the first home buyer concessions

This is the largest and least discussed cost. NSW duty concessions for first home buyers require you to live in the property. Buy an investment first and you generally forfeit the exemption — which on an $800,000 purchase is a very substantial sum — along with the First Home Owner Grant.

Whether you can claim them later on a subsequent purchase depends on the rules at that time and on whether you still count as a first home buyer, which owning an investment property may prevent. This alone can decide the question, so price it before anything else. See the stamp duty calculator for what the concession is worth.

You lose the main residence exemption

Your own home is generally exempt from capital gains tax. An investment property is not. Every dollar of growth on a rentvested property is potentially taxable on sale, with a discount for holding beyond twelve months. Over a long hold that is a large difference against the alternative of owning where you live.

You are a tenant and a landlord at once

You can be asked to leave your rental at the end of a lease, and rents rise. Meanwhile you carry vacancies, repairs, management fees, insurance, land tax and difficult tenants at the other property. Some people find this trade comfortable. Others find it the worst of both positions.

When the numbers genuinely favour it

Rentvesting works best where there is a wide gap between the cost of renting and the cost of buying in the same area. If renting a home costs far less than the mortgage, rates and maintenance on an equivalent purchase, the difference invested elsewhere can compound in your favour.

It works least well where rent and mortgage costs are close, because then you are paying similar money for the same roof without building equity in it. The rent vs buy calculator is the right place to test this with your actual rent and target price.

The other factor is the quality of what you buy. Buying a poor investment in a cheap area to get into the market is not a strategy — it is just a purchase. If the property does not grow, you have taken on landlord obligations and forfeited concessions for nothing. Check the rental yield calculator and be sceptical of anywhere with a single employer, oversupplied apartments, or a yield that looks high because nobody wants to live there.

Who it tends to suit

It often works for: people whose work may relocate them; those who want to live in an area they cannot realistically buy in for a decade; higher earners who benefit more from deductibility; and people who are genuinely comfortable being a landlord.

It often does not work for: first home buyers who would qualify for substantial duty concessions; people who want the security of not being asked to move; anyone who would find a vacancy or a large repair financially stressful; and those who would spend rather than invest the difference, which quietly defeats the entire premise.

The structural points to get right

  • Do not cross-collateralise if you later buy a home as well. Keep each property secured by its own loan.
  • Use an offset, not redraw, and keep savings offsetting non-deductible debt if you have any.
  • Keep records from day one. Deductions, depreciation schedules and the cost base for capital gains all depend on documentation you will not be able to reconstruct in ten years.
  • Check land tax. An investment property may take you over the NSW threshold, and it is an annual cost.
  • Model the exit. If the plan is to sell and buy a home later, work out what capital gains tax and the loss of concessions do to the proceeds.

Common questions

Generally not on an investment purchase, because the grant and the duty concessions require you to live in the property. Whether a later purchase qualifies depends on the rules then and on whether owning an investment has already disqualified you. Check with Revenue NSW before deciding.

Sometimes, and it depends on the gap between rent and ownership costs in your area. Where renting is much cheaper than buying, the strategy has room to work. Where they are close, it usually does not.

Your rent is counted as an ongoing expense in the servicing assessment, which reduces borrowing capacity compared with an owner-occupier who has no rent. Lenders also count only part of the expected rental income, commonly around 80%.

Yes, and this is a common plan. There are capital gains tax consequences from the change of use, and the calculation apportions the gain across the periods it was an investment and a home. Get advice from an accountant before you make the switch.

Yes. Your own home is generally exempt; an investment property is not. Growth on a rentvested property is potentially taxable on sale, with a discount for holding longer than twelve months.

Benjamin Marzouk

Mortgage broker, LNB Finance

Benjamin Marzouk is the broker behind LNB Finance, working with clients across the St George, Bayside and Sutherland Shire areas from Sans Souci, and arranging finance Australia-wide. He compares more than 60 lenders and is not owned by, or aligned to, any bank.

Credit Representative 551447 under Australian Credit Licence 384324, held by Outsource Financial Pty Ltd. LNB Finance Pty Ltd, ABN 83 668 176 083, and is subject to the Best Interests Duty. Both licence numbers are publicly searchable on ASIC Connect. Read our Credit Guide.

Weighing up rentvesting against buying a home?

We will price what the concessions are worth and what you would give up, so the comparison is a real one.

Related

Call 0480 040 239 Get assessed