Loan Types and Structure

Fixed vs Variable Home Loan: How to Actually Decide

Fixing is not a bet on rates. It is buying certainty, and certainty has a price.

A fixed rate locks your repayment for a set term, usually one to five years. A variable rate moves with the market and generally comes with an offset account, unlimited extra repayments and no break costs. Fixing is worth it when a stable repayment genuinely matters to your household, not when you think you can outguess the market — because the lenders setting the fixed rate have already priced in what they expect to happen.

The question is almost always framed as a prediction: will rates go up or down? That framing is a trap. Fixed rates are set by lenders who employ people to forecast this for a living, and the expected path is already priced into the rate you are offered. You are not betting against the market. You are choosing how much uncertainty you want to carry.

What each one actually gives you

 FixedVariable
Repayment certaintyYes, for the termNo
Offset accountRarely, or partialUsually
Extra repaymentsUsually cappedUsually unlimited
Cost to exit earlyBreak costs, can be largeSmall or none
Benefit if rates fallNonePassed on

Read that table as a trade rather than a scoreboard. Fixing buys certainty and pays for it in flexibility.

Break costs, which are the real risk of fixing

This is the part that causes genuine financial harm, and it is poorly understood.

If you exit a fixed loan early — by selling, refinancing, or repaying a large lump sum — the lender can charge a break cost. It is not a flat penalty. It is calculated on the loss the lender incurs from unwinding the funding it arranged for your fixed term, and it moves with wholesale rates.

The consequence: break costs are near zero when rates have risen since you fixed, and potentially very large when rates have fallen. Which means the moment you most want to escape a fixed loan is precisely the moment it is most expensive to do so. That is not the lender being unfair; it is the arithmetic of how the product is funded. But it should be understood before you fix, not after.

Before you fix, ask yourself honestly: could I need to sell, refinance or repay a large sum within this term? A job move, a growing family, a relationship change, an inheritance. If any of those is plausible, the fixed term should be shorter, or you should not fix at all.

The offset problem

Most fixed loans do not offer a full offset account, and those that do often restrict it. If you keep meaningful savings, this matters more than a small rate difference.

An offset account reduces the interest you pay by the balance sitting in it, while keeping that money accessible. Someone holding a substantial buffer can be materially better off on a slightly higher variable rate with a working offset than on a lower fixed rate without one. Run your own figures on the offset account calculator before assuming the lower rate wins.

Fixed loans also typically cap extra repayments. If your plan is to pay the loan down aggressively, a cap is a genuine constraint rather than a technicality.

Splitting, and when it is the honest answer

A split loan fixes part of the balance and leaves the rest variable. You get partial repayment certainty, keep an offset against the variable portion, and can make unlimited extra repayments on that portion.

It is often described as hedging your bets, which slightly undersells it. A split is genuinely useful when your circumstances are mixed: you need a predictable core repayment, but you also have savings to offset, or you might make lump sum repayments, or you are not certain how long you will hold the property.

It is not a way to be right either way. You will always be able to look back and see that fully fixing or fully floating would have been better. That is not the point; the point is that it reduces the consequences of being wrong. The split loan calculator models different proportions.

Who should fix, and who should not

Fixing tends to suit

  • Households where a rise in repayments would cause real difficulty rather than mild inconvenience.
  • Buyers who have stretched to purchase and have little buffer.
  • Investors who need predictable holding costs to model cash flow.
  • Anyone on a fixed or tightly constrained income.

Fixing tends not to suit

  • Anyone likely to sell or refinance within the term.
  • Borrowers with substantial savings who would lose the benefit of an offset.
  • People planning large extra repayments or expecting a lump sum.
  • Anyone fixing purely because they believe rates will rise. That view is already in the price.

The end of the fixed term matters as much as the start

Fixed loans revert to a variable rate when the term ends, and the revert rate is very often not competitive. Lenders rely on inertia here, and a great many borrowers simply roll onto it and stay.

Whatever you decide now, put a reminder in your calendar for two months before your fixed term ends. That is the moment to renegotiate or move, and it is worth real money. We have written separately about what happens when a fixed rate ends.

Common questions

Over a full loan term there is no reliable answer, because it depends on rate movements nobody can forecast. What can be assessed properly is which structure suits your circumstances, your buffer and your plans for the property. That is a question with an answer.

It depends entirely on how wholesale rates have moved since you fixed, how much time is left, and the size of the balance. They can be negligible or they can run into many thousands. Your lender must tell you the figure on request, and you should ask before doing anything that might trigger it.

Usually up to an annual cap, with penalties beyond it. Caps differ significantly between lenders, so if extra repayments are part of your plan, check the specific limit rather than assuming.

Yes. A split loan fixes one portion and leaves the other variable, so you keep an offset and extra repayment flexibility on the variable part. It is a common and sensible structure.

The loan reverts to a variable rate, frequently an uncompetitive one. Set a reminder for around two months before expiry so you can renegotiate or refinance rather than defaulting onto whatever the lender offers.

Benjamin Marzouk

Mortgage broker, LNB Finance

Benjamin Marzouk is the broker behind LNB Finance, working with clients across the St George, Bayside and Sutherland Shire areas from Sans Souci, and arranging finance Australia-wide. He compares more than 60 lenders and is not owned by, or aligned to, any bank.

Credit Representative 551447 under Australian Credit Licence 384324, held by Outsource Financial Pty Ltd. LNB Finance Pty Ltd, ABN 83 668 176 083, and is subject to the Best Interests Duty. Both licence numbers are publicly searchable on ASIC Connect. Read our Credit Guide.

Weighing up fixing, and want it modelled properly?

We will run fixed, variable and split against your actual balance, savings and plans, and tell you which suits your situation.

Related

Call 0480 040 239 Get assessed